Purpose This scoping review aimed to identify the current state of the application of theories in research related to advance care planning and to analyze the types and characteristics of the theories applied.
Methods: Using the scoping review methodology presented by Arksey & O'Malley, the articles published from 2010 to 2022 were searched by combining the terms "advance care planning," "theory," and "model" in five electronic databases; PubMed, CINAHL, EMBASE, KMBASE, and KISS.
Results: Thirty-two studies were identified. Theory-based research has been actively conducted since 2019, with a total of 25 theories applied. Psychological theories were the most prevalent, accounting for 75.0% of the applications, followed by sociological theories (12.5%), public health theories (6.3%), and one nursing theory (3.1%). Theories were utilized to create a framework for data analysis, establish a philosophical underpinning, develop intervention frameworks, and derive new tools.
Conclusion: Various theories have been applied to research on advance care planning, yet the application of nursing theory has been limited. To optimize end-of-life care and advance care planning from a nursing perspective, further research incorporating nursing theory is essential.
PURPOSE As advanced medical care has resulted in the unintended consequence of prolonging deaths, there is a growing interest in the decision to withhold life-sustaining treatments. The purpose of this study was to determine factors associated with the decision to withhold life-sustaining treatments in middle-aged and older adults who die in hospital in the United States. METHODS This cross-sectional correlational study conducted secondary analysis of 2000–2012 exit interview data from the Health and Retirement Study. Adults aged 50 and older who died in hospital and who had made a decision regarding life-sustaining treatments were included. Multivariable logistic regression was used to identify factors related to the decision to withhold life-sustaining treatments. RESULTS Among 1,412 adults, the prevalence of the decision to withhold life-sustaining treatments was 61.1%. Significant factors associated with the decision to withhold life-sustaining treatments were being African American (Adjusted Odds Ratio [AOR]=0.50, 95% Confidential Interval [CI]=0.30~0.86), Catholic (AOR=0.5, 95% CI=0.32~0.93), having at least one private insurance policy (AOR=1.40, 95% CI=1.02~1.92), having a living will (AOR=1.71, 95% CI=1.04~2.83), and having discussed end-of-life care with someone (AOR=1.810, 95% CI=1.25~2.62). CONCLUSION Differences in race and religious affiliation should be considered when older adults, family members, and health care providers make decisions regarding life-sustaining treatments at the end-of-life. Also, health insurance coverage for advance care planning makes it easier for people to discuss life-sustaining treatments with health care providers.
PURPOSE The aims of this study were to identify the reported attitudes of older patients with cancer toward advance directives (ADs) and the factors associated with their attitudes toward ADs. METHODS The design was a cross-sectional survey. The age mean of the 130 participants were 70.8, and 66.2% of the participants were male. The data were collected at one university hospital in Seoul, South Korea during the period from October 1st to December 5th in 2013. The data collecting instruments were the Advance Directives Attitude Survey (ADAS) and questionnaires including socio-demographic and disease-related characteristics, family function. RESULTS 30.0% of the participants were aware of ADs, only 9% of them had been informed by healthcare providers. Most participants (93.1%) intended to complete ADs. The mean score of ADAS was 48.29. The stepwise linear regression analysis indicated that family function, perceived health status, period of education, and age accounted for a significant percentage (52.0%, p<.001) of the variance in participants' ADAS. The variable with the greatest effect was family function. CONCLUSION The findings suggest that family function and attitude of older cancer patients need to be considered for adapting ADs to Korean health care systems. Healthcare providers should include family members in advanced care planning discussions.
Citations
Citations to this article as recorded by
Factors Affecting Intention of Signing the Advance Directives in Middle Aged Adults in Korea Based on the Theory of Planned Behavior: A Cross-sectional Study Hyun Jeong Park, Kyu Eun Lee Journal of Health Informatics and Statistics.2024; 49(3): 279. CrossRef
Factors That Influence Attitudes toward Advance Directives among Female Cancer Patients Aeri Kim, Kisook Kim The Korean Journal of Hospice and Palliative Care.2023; 26(2): 80. CrossRef
Making decisions on life-sustaining treatment among Koreans: a population-based nationwide survey Ae-Ran Kim, Kwang-Hwan Kim, Seok-Hwan Bae, Jung-Hee Park, Chiara Achangwa, Moo-Sik Lee Journal of Global Health Science.2022;[Epub] CrossRef
Factors Influencing Advanced Directives Among Hemodialysis Patients Eunseong SON, Minjeong SEO Korean Journal of Medical Ethics.2022; 25(3): 243. CrossRef
Factors Affecting Intention of Signing an Advanced Directives in Cancer Patients Eun-Ju Ha, Mee Ock Gu Journal of Korean Academy of Fundamentals of Nursing.2021; 28(1): 121. CrossRef
Modifiable Factors Associated with the Completion of Advance Treatment Directives in Hematologic Malignancy: A Patient–Caregiver Dyadic Analysis JinShil Kim, Jinny Park, Mee Ok Lee, Eun Young Park, Seongkum Heo, Jae Lan Shim Journal of Palliative Medicine.2020; 23(5): 611. CrossRef
Attitudes toward advance directives and prognosis in patients with heart failure: a pilot study JinShil Kim, Minjeong An, Seongkum Heo, Mi-Seung Shin The Korean Journal of Internal Medicine.2020; 35(1): 109. CrossRef
Associations of Advance Directive Knowledge, Attitudes, and Barriers/Benefits With Preferences for Advance Treatment Directives Among Patients With Heart Failure and Their Caregivers JINSHIL KIM, MI-SEUNG SHIN, YAE MIN PARK, HYANG-NANG LEE, SEONGKUM HEO, SONGTHIP OUNPRASEUTH Journal of Cardiac Failure.2020; 26(1): 61. CrossRef
Psychometric Testing of the Korean Version of the Attitudes toward the Advance Directives in Low-Income Chronically Ill Older Adults JinShil Kim, Seongkum Heo, Sun Woo Hong, HeeRyang Kim, Ahrang Jung, Minjeong An, JaeLan Shim Healthcare.2020; 8(1): 62. CrossRef
Development of Advance Directives for Nursing Home Residents Kyem Ju Lee, Sung Ok Chang Journal of Korean Gerontological Nursing.2019; 21(2): 75. CrossRef
The Relationship among Attitudes toward the Withdrawal of Life-sustaining Treatment, Death Anxiety, and Death Acceptance among Hospitalized Elderly Cancer Patients YeonMi Seo, Sujin Shin Asian Oncology Nursing.2019; 19(3): 142. CrossRef
Good Death Awareness, Attitudes toward Advance Directives and Preferences for Care Near the End of Life among Hospitalized Elders in Long-term Care Hospitals Eunju Kim, Yoonju Lee Journal of Korean Academy of Fundamentals of Nursing.2019; 26(3): 197. CrossRef
The Korean–Advance Directive Model and Factors Associated With Its Completion Among Patients With Hematologic Disorders Mee Ok Lee, Jinny Park, Eun Young Park, Youngji Kim, Eunjoo Bang, Seongkum Heo, JinShil Kim Journal of Hospice & Palliative Nursing.2019; 21(4): E10. CrossRef
Comparison of forecasting models of disease occurrence due to the weather in elderly patients Seonjae Lee, In-Kwon Yeo Korean Journal of Applied Statistics.2016; 29(1): 145. CrossRef